The Italian Law Journal | ItaLJ




Italy in Egypt and Historical Influences on Egyptian Codification

by G.M. Piccinelli

The presence of a large community of Italians in Egypt has assumed a meaningful dimension from the mid-XIX to the mid-XX century. Even if its economic and social profile was generally modest, it succeeded in creating schools, places of worship and meeting attended also by the Egyptian élites and by the members of other nationalities. [...]



Italian Constitutional Court, Kelsen’s Pure Theory and Solving ‘Hard’ Cases 

by Z. Akhtar

The legal system is a kernel of rules in which the crucial role is that of the law making body. The most important factor in the promulgation of laws is the ability to challenge any unfair or unjust law by invoking the powers of judicial review. In Italy, which practices a Civil law jurisdiction there is a constitutional court that conducts the judicial review of laws that concern the citizens.  […]


General Remarks on Civil Liability in the European Context

by G. Alpa

This article considers the evolution of the civil liability system in Europe from the perspective of the establishment and application of rules deriving from regulations and directives that define special types of torts. Neither the EU rules nor the principles developed by the Court of Justice always identify all the necessary components of the tortious act. […]


Unfair Contract Terms Before the Italian Competition Authority (ICA)

by M. Angelone

The newly-introduced Art 37-bis of the Consumer Code provided the Italian Competition Authority (ICA) with new powers aimed at scrutinizing – ex ante or ex post – the unfairness of the terms included in standard contracts between traders and consumers. This paper analyses the legislative provision (as supplemented by secondary regulation) in view of the decisions adopted by the ICA […]


The Prohibition of Discrimination as a Limit on Contractual Autonomy

by G. Carapezza Figlia

The essay analyzes the progressive assertion of non-discrimination as a principle within Italian and European contract law. After having examinated the legislative concept of contractual discrimination, the scope of the prohibition and the extent of its impact, the Author shows that the direct applicability of the principle of equality within private law relations is inseparable from the issue of the review of contractual autonomy […]


Claims-Made Insurance Policies in Italy: The Domestic Story and Suggestions from the UK, Canada and Australia

by F. Delfini

Liability insurance contacts can be divided into two main categories: loss occurrence based and claims-made based. While the Italian Civil Code (ICC) only considers and determines insurance contracts on a loss occurrence basis, since the end of the 20th century, the claims-made model has taken control of the market. This reception has posed various issues in the domestic legal system on which the Italian Supreme Court has recently ruled several times. […]


The Italian Marriage: Crisis or Tradition?

by R. Fadda

Numerous reforms of Italian family law have been enacted in recent years regarding marriage, which reinforce the freedom of the spouses and which have provoked a crisis of the institution itself. The tendency emerging from the new laws reveals an accentuation of the married couple’s autonomy and of the public authority’s limited role in the different phases of marriage.  […]


The Recoverability of the Loss of the Right to Life per se: A Brief European Overview

by P. Sanna

Traditionally, with a few exceptions, in Europe, decisions of the courts have denied the recoverability of the loss of the right to life per se (and the subsequent transfer of the claim from the primary victim to his/her heirs).  […]


Will Formalities in the Digital Age: Some Comparative Remarks

by I. Sasso

The work proposes to examine current testamentary will formalities in light of the digital revolution that has swept through modern society these past decades. The analysis will concentrate on the extent to which each of the three forms of ordinary testamentary will governed by Italian law is compatible with new electronic and digital technologies.  […]


Apathy Revisited

by C. Skach

Contemporary world events, characterized by violence and extremism, force us to revisit the potential uses and abuses of political apathy in democracy. This article unravels the concept of apathy, placing it within its semantic field, qualifying it with respect to different political contexts, and making it relative to its possible conceptual opposites.[…]


The GDPR and the LIBE Study on the Use of Hacking Tools by Law Enforcement Agencies

by G. Ziccardi

Digital information is, today, at the center of the cultural, social, technological and political discussions, above all with reference to its protection. In the age of big data, automated processing of information, large-scale use of algorithms and profiling systems, the risk of losing control over data and the fear of activities carried out in violation of the rights of the individuals, are very real. […]



Res Iudicata in Breach of the ECHR:
The Italian Constitutional Court’s Point of View

by C. Petta

In the judgment no 123 of 2017 the Italian Constitutional Court declared inadmissible the question of constitutionality stemming from a Code of Administrative Procedure provision (Art 106) in the part in which it does not provide for the possibility to review a ruling in cases of conflict between domestic judgments and judgments of the Court of Strasbourg.[…]


The Duty to Inform and Voidable Investment Orders

by M. Semeraro

The definition of the relationship between framework contracts and individual investment orders has always been the subject of debate both in legal scholarship and in case law, as it is functional to the solution of various application issues.  […]


‘A Case with Peculiarities’: Mixed Same-Sex Marriages Before the Supreme Court

by M.M. Winkler

This article examines the judgment of the Italian Supreme Court (Corte di Cassazione) no 11696 of 14 May 2018 concerning the legal status of mixed same-sex married couples under Italian law. It explores the problems relating to the recognition and the civil status registration in Italy of couples of the same sex where one spouse is a foreigner and the other is Italian. […]








Carlo Cattaneo and Gaetano Salvemini: The Modernity of their Federalism

by E. Arban

Federalism and federal solutions in Italy have never enjoyed much popularity, although they have been discussed at different times as viable solutions for a country fragmented along socio-economic and linguistic lines. This mistrust can be partially explained by the fact that federalism has been often misunderstood and construed as synonymous with division and disintegration of the territory.  [...]


Nel Buio delle Folti Tenebre dell’Ordinamento.
Justice and Law in the Provinces of the Kingdom of Naples During the Modern Era (17 th Century)

by A. Di Falco

This work focuses on the Neapolitan Jus Regni and judicial activities of the baronial courts in the Kingdom of Napoli during the early modern period; and in particular, the thorny activity of applying the law in the provincial territories in which individual cases could be subject to different procedural methods deriving from the statutory legislation in effect in each. […]



The Constitutional Impact of the Exceptio Inadimpleti Contractus

by A.M. Benedetti

This article deals with the proposition that the exception of non-performance – suspending the execution of a given performance – engages the enjoyment of constitutionally-protected rights. Using inspiration from interesting Colombian jurisprudence, the author believes that, in such cases, the control over the use of the exceptio inadimpleti contractus can no longer be entrusted  […]


Unioni Civili: Same-Sex Partnerships Law in Italy

by N. Cipriani

This essay analyzes the main aspects of legge 20 May 2016 no 76, which allowed same-sex partnership in Italy. In particular, it seeks to reflect upon the elements that most differentiate the regulation of same-sex partnerships from that of marriages, in order to better understand whether these differences are entirely justified and reasonable. […]


Constitutional Axiology and Party Autonomy

by F. Criscuolo

The Italian Constitution is based on strong values of personalism and solidarity. As a matter of fact, autonomy, freedom and right of self-determination are not absolute values, but values among other values. The Contract, as source of rules governing economic relations, should be subjected to a test of worthiness (meritevolezza) according to the constitutional values […]


Financial and Energy Contracts: New Demands for the Regulation and Categorization of Contracts

by C. Ferrari

According to recent European regulations, certain kinds of contracts, mostly derivatives with an underlying energy product, risk being included, by virtue of the predominance afforded to the financial aspects, within the realm of financial contracts and consequently subject to the full extent of the legislation governing the latter. […]


The Civil Wrong Between Private Relationships and Social Order

by A. Lasso

A new approach to the functions of liability allows the observation of civil wrong from two different perspectives: the relationship between the wrongdoer and the injured party and the system of values in its natural aspiration to stability. The unjust harm caused by the wrongdoer may entail the reinstatement of the victim’s property and the concomitant protection of important social interests. […]


Wrongful Birth and Wrongful Life Actions
(The Experience in Portugal as a Continental Civil Law Country)

by V.L. Raposo

This article presents a brief overview of how medical liability for wrongful birth and wrongful life issues is addressed under continental civil law in Portugal. It analyses the requisites for tort liability (wrongfulness, culpability, causation and damage), then explores how these elements operate in wrongful birth and life lawsuits. […]


Godzilla and the Japanese Constitution: A Comparison Between Italy and Japan

by J. Tsuji

The Japanese movie ‘Godzilla’ illuminated controversial issues related to the existence of the Self Defense Force (SDF) under the current Japanese Constitution. In this movie, the Japanese Government sent the SDF, emergency power, and leadership of the prime minister to fight against an external enemy, Godzilla. […]



Corporate and Financial Markets Law: A New Section

by M. Ventoruzzo


The Expanding Boundaries of MiFID’s Duty to Act in the Client’s Best Interest: The Italian Case

by L. Enriques and M. Gargantini

MiFID requires investment firms to act in accordance with the best interests of their clients. This overarching principle shapes firms’ professional conduct in at least two ways. First, it sets a general standard firms have to comply with when dealing with their clients and its breach may lead to civil remedies for clients or administrative sanctions for investment firms. […]


Principals vs Principals: The Twilight of the ‘Agency Theory’

by F. Denozza and A. Stabilini

In this article, we maintain that the agency theory of the corporation, that has dominated the corporate law debate for the last four decades, offers a trivial and reductive description of the problems of the corporation, ignores the most significant phenomena and offers a distorted picture of issues that the law must solve. […]


The 2016 Italian Consolidated Law on Public Entities Owned Companies: Towards a More Consistent Private Law Approach

by M. Allena and F. Goisis

This article aims to analyze the model of company emerging from the new Italian consolidated law on public entities owned companies of 2016, coming to the conclusion that, especially given the principles of the legislative delegation and the European Union law requirements, such companies are characterized as fully for profit and private. […]


The Legal Transplant into Italian Law of the Procédure d’Alerte. Duties and Responsibilities of the Companies’ Bodies

by F. Pernazza

The Italian Law on Bankruptcy of 1942 has been amended and integrated several times on specific subjects, but until now, the total reform proposal has failed. Finally, in October 2017, a statute has been approved that establishes new principles on the entrepreneurial crisis and insolvency and delegates powers to the the Government to enable it to elaborate an organic reform of rules and procedures. […]



Suicide: Not in the Wrong Moment, Please!

by C. Baldus and P.-C. Müller-Graff

The authors welcome the landmark decision of the Corte Costituzionale as the right step in the right moment. With a special accent on EU Law and Roman Law, they point out Italy’s role in European Legal Science. The EU law paradigm of linguistic equality fits perfectly to Europe’s long-term common interest, before and after Brexit. […]


The Grand Chamber’s Stand on the Punitive Damages Dilemma

by L. Coppo

It is a truth universally acknowledged that corrective justice is the pillar on which the whole system of remedies rests in principle and modern tort liability revolves around the idea of compensation. Deeply anchored to that conception, Italian case law has been impervious to punitive damages, on the grounds of their alleged inconsistency with public policy, until its latest developments. […]



Privacy in Europe after Regulation (EU) No. 2016/679: What Will Remain of the Right to be Forgotten?

by F. Di Ciommo

Regulation (EU) no 2016/679 (hereinafter ‘GDPR’), which will become applicable throughout the EU from next May and will replace Directive 95/46/EC, contains the first legislative embodiment of the right to be forgotten. In other words, the personal right that, thanks also to the well known Google Spain case, has captured the attention of operators and academics alike. […]


Privacy or Transparency? A New Balancing of Interests for the Right to be Forgotten in the Field of Personal Data Published in Public Registers

by O. Pollicino and G. De Gregorio

The European Court of Justice, in a decision dated 9 March 2017, dealt with the right of individuals to request of the authority responsible for maintaining the companies register the elimination (‘right to be forgotten’) of personal data concerning them entered in that register. […]



Review of a monograph: Das Grundbuch im Europa des XXI. Jahrhunderts edited by Arkadiusz Wudarski

by J. Gołaczyński





Is Libertarianism Thick or Thin? Thin!

by W.E. Block and K. Williamson

Thin libertarianism, and only thin libertarianism, is valid libertarianism. Thick libertarianism is actually an attempt to hijack real, or thin, libertarianism. The present paper is devoted to stopping thick libertarianism in its tracks. We take as foils thick libertarians Johnson (2013) and Tucker (2014) and demonstrate that their thick libertarian views are contrary to true libertarianism. [...]


The Civil Responsibility of the Italian Judiciary: A Double Speed System

by A. Cilento

This work illustrates the critical issues regarding the civil responsibility of Italian judges as regulated by legge 27 February 2015 no 18,  modified by legge 13 April 1988 no 117 on compensation for damage arising in the execution of judicial office and the civil liability of judges. […]


Justice, Fault, and Efficiency in Contract Law 

by L.A. DiMatteo

This article explores some of the core concepts that underlie contract law. It rejects the feasibility of a uniform theory of contract law including a critique of the economic analysis of contract law. The importance of efficient contract rules and efficient contracts is not disputed, but efficiency’s explanatory power is limited due to the breadth of contract law, as well as the complexity […]


On Abuse of Rights and Judicial Creativity  

by N. Lipari

The abuse of rights doctrine, which has received renewed attention in the judicial and scholarly debates, raises the fundamental tension between the formal attribution of a right and the concrete exercise of that right. In this article, the Author argues that the abuse of rights paradigm should not be reduced to asking only whether conduct is legal or illegal. […]


Marital Contracts and Private Ordering of Marriage from the Italian Family Law Perspective

by R. Montinaro

The essay is centred on the role played by private ordering in regulating the financial terms of marriage dissolution. The Italian legal scholars’ attitude regarding this issue has changed over time. It has transformed from a paternalistic perspective, mostly rejecting the spousal parties’ freedom, to a novel view that favours an expanded role for contracts to determine […]


Functions of Soft Law in Transnational and Local Governance: A Case of the Land Rush in the Mekong Region

by N. Okano

This paper analyzes land law history in the Mekong region, a recent land rush there, and the Voluntary Guidelines on the Responsible Governance of Tenure of Land, Fisheries and Forests (VGGT), a soft law measure on governance of tenure. This work will generally illustrate recent developments of land governance. […]


Legal Principles and Values 

by P. Perlingieri

This paper analyses in depth the distinction between values and principles in light of the process of legal interpretation. The logical and legal status of principles are examined from a conceptual standpoint at the outset, as well as the slippery border between principles and values and the interplay between law, politics and ethics. […]


The Legal Anatomy of Electronic Platforms: A Prior Study to Assess the Need of a Law of Platforms in the EU

by T. Rodriguez de las Heras Ballell

Digital economy is nowadays a Platform economy. This pervading expansion of platforms has been triggered by their value-creating ability and trust-generation potential. The emergence and increasing popularity of disruptive models, such as sharing-based economy, crowdfunding or fintech variants, have been greatly accelerated by platform-based solutions. […]


Constitutional Values and Judge-Made Law

by G. Scaccia

The Author contends that value-oriented constitutionalism marks a shifting of law making function from political bodies to the Courts. In fact judges act as legislators for the concrete case: they have to dispense justice according to law, but law is made up of constitutional values which can be implemented in multiple and, at times, opposite ways. […]


Horizontal Effects of Constitutional Rights in the Internet: A Legal Case on the Digital Constitution

by G. Teubner

This article discusses whether websites criticizing the environmental policies of multinational enterprises are protected by horizontal effects of human rights and develops three theses: (1) The third-party effect has so far been configured in an individualist perspective only, as balancing individual constitutional rights of private actors against each other. […]



Same-Sex Adoptions: The Italian Case

by M. Farina

In the judgment discussed in this paper, the Court of Cassation endorsed a broad interpretation of Art 44, para 1, letter d), legge 4 May 1983 no 184, such as to allow ‘adoption in special cases’ to homosexual couples. The legal recognition of the parental relationship developed between the child and the partner of the biological parent is rooted in a constitutionally-oriented interpretation, […]


The Child’s Surname in the Light of Italian Constitutional Legality

by L. Tullio

The Italian Constitutional Court declared unconstitutional the legal rule that every child must be attributed the father’s surname at birth or adoption or in case of recognition by both parents (joint recognition), and cannot also be attributed the mother’s surname, even if requested by both parents. This article examines the legal arguments raised by the Court, […]




by P. Grossi


Methods and Purposes of the Constitutional Court Watch

by P. Passaglia







The Italian Reform of the Law on Filiation and Constitutional Legality

by C. Cicero

There is a tendency within modern legal systems towards mitigating or eliminating the differences between filiation within or outside of wedlock. The Italian law on filiation has been subject to important reforms driven by constitutional law, with the aim of guaranteeing equality between children. The endpoint of this legislative process has been to stipulate one single status for all children. [...]


Confidentiality and the (Un)Sustainable Development of the Internet

by M. D'Ambrosio

The right to privacy is compromised on a daily basis by the commercial practices of today’s information society. The Schrems case is an example of the risks of the processing of personal data on the internet. The European regulatory system for the protection of personal data cannot ensure effective protection of its citizens’ information. Therefore, this article proposes a reconceptualisation […]


The Italian Class Action: 
New Paradigm or ‘Much Ado about Nothing’?

by C. d'Orta

For several years there has been an increasing awareness that in order effectively to protect consumers’ rights, it is necessary to improve legal action through the use of more adequate tools. This has stimulated efforts by policy makers and regulators worldwide to introduce actions for damages in their legal systems in the wake of the US experience of the class action […]


Good Faith and Pre-Contractual Liability in Italy: Recent Developments in the Interpretation of Article 1337 of the Italian Civil Code

by T. Febbrajo

In Italy, pre-contractual liability is governed by a statutory provision that requires parties to act in good faith during the negotiation and formation of the contract (Art 1337 Civil Code). Nonetheless, since the entry into force in Italy of the current 1942 Civil Code, Art 1337 has been consistently given a narrow interpretation. From this narrow perspective, pre-contractual liability applies only in two cases […]


Transfer of Ownership and Preliminary Agreements

by P. Gallo

This work aims to provide a contribution to the standardization of European law in the field of transfer of ownership. At first sight, the European scenario appears to present a very marked contrast between the French model of transfer of property based on the contract (titulus), and the German one, which is based on delivery (modus). […]


International Issues Regarding Surrogacy

by I. Kriari and A. Valongo

The global spread of surrogacy and the changes to the concept of family resulting from historical, social and cultural factors should lead lawmakers to address the issue of children born through this procedure. This should draw both on the most recent academic literature as well as an interdisciplinary perspective. The purpose of this article is to propose solutions on an international level […]


Liquid Citizenship — Citizens’ Rights in the European Union

by M. La Torre

My paper is structured in three sections. In the first, I will introduce a debate about the form of the modern State in terms of a ‘conditional’ and ‘purposive’ programme. This debate was particularly acute in the late Seventies and Eighties, and gave rise to an alternative presented as ‘responsive’ or ‘reflective’. However, and this is my point in this first section, this alternative in a context of globalisation […]


Machine Rules. Of Drones, Robots, and the Info-Capitalist Society

by G. Noto La Diega

Italy has been one of the first countries in the world to enact ad hoc regulations on drones. Therefore, the Italian approach may constitute a model for many regulations to come; nonetheless, the legal literature seems to overlook the phenomenon. In this article, I place the discourse on drones in the context of some more general considerations on the main legal issues […]


Making a Centralized System of Judicial Review Coexist with Decentralized Guardians of the Constitution: The Italian Way

by P. Passaglia

In the aftermaths of World War II, a mechanism for constitutional review was set up, to provide the system with means of reacting against infringements of the Supreme Law. Even though a Constitutional Court was established, the Italian system of constitutional adjudication is only partially inspired by Kelsen’s centralized model: […]



The Notion of ‘Cultural Diversity’ in the EU Trade Agreements and Negotiations: New Challenges and Perspectives 

by L. Bellucci

This article analyses the notion of ‘cultural diversity’ as adopted within and adapted for the European Union’s (EU) external trade relations. Its law in context approach, underlines the socio-political framework in which the notion of ‘cultural diversity’ has taken shape, and the conflicting interests involved in its negotiation, promotion and protection.  […]


A Critical Comparative Analysis of Online Tools for Legal Translations

by P. Giampieri

In the current fast-paced digital world, legal translators are often confronted with a vast array of online resources that they can hardly use or understand. This paper aims to outline some of the pitfalls arising from the Internet for legal translators and the shortcomings of some online tools. In particular, it will analyse and compare online dictionaries, fora, […]



Carolene in Reverse
Contractual Interpretation for Dismantling the Dictatorship of ‘Discrete and Insular Minorities’ in Transnational Private Ordering Regimes

by P. Femia


Some Inconvenient Truths About Antitrust Law and Economics

by J.L. Harrison

United States’ antitrust policy and, to a lesser extent, that of the European Union stress three economic goals – consumer surplus, allocative efficiency, and productive efficiency. When they are discussed or debated, antitrust scholars omit a number of points that undercut their desirability. This Essay describes them briefly and highlights their frailties.  […]



The Social-Environmental Function of Property and the EU ‘Polluter Pays’ Principle: The Compatibility between Italian and European Law

by V. Corriero

This article analyses the legal scholarship and Italian jurisprudential debate over the obligations imposed on an owner who is not the polluter of a contaminated site, a debate which culminated in a landmark decision by the European Court of Justice on 4 March 2015. The ‘social-environmental’ function of property provides the most appropriate balance […]


The Worthiness of Claims Made Clauses in Liability Insurance Contracts

by S. Landini

The Italian Supreme Court has ruled on the worthiness control of clauses in insurance contracts and particularly of the claims made clauses contained in insurance policies against professional liability. This essay examines the conclusions of the Court with some considerations about the issue of the adequacy of the insurance products in respect to the needs of policyholders. […]



Guido Calabresi’s The Future of Law & Economics

by R.A. Porrata-Doria and M. Grondona





Utilitarianism and Retributivism in Cesare Beccaria

by M. De Caro

In analyzing Cesare Beccaria’s theory of punishment, this article emphasizes that, while he clearly endorsed a proto-utilitarian theory of punishment strongly at odds with positive retributivism, he also accepted some elements of negative retributivism. This fact, however, should not be seen as weakness of Beccaria’s view, but as another proof of his genius. As a matter of fact, he acutely understood that a purely utilitarian conception of punishment [...]


On the Importance of Sharing National Law so as to Shape Future Trans-National Legal Solutions

by D. Wallis



The Performance of the Italian Civil Justice System: An Empirical Assessment

by R. Caponi

The unreasonable length of Italian civil proceedings goes on filling pages of newspapers and magazines. According to some authoritative views, the inefficiency of the civil justice system helps explain why the Italian model of legislation and scholarship in civil procedure is not as influential on the European scene as it was in the past. Interestingly enough, a nearly diametrically opposed thesis has also been advanced, […]


Post Rule of Law: The Structural Problem of Hybridity in International Criminal Procedure

by K.B. Carlson

The value of developing hybrid international criminal procedure (ICP) is that it is arguably inclusive (representing two major legal traditions) and distinct from any domestic system, thus creating a separate, sui generis realm for international criminal law (ICL) jurists to meet. Since its inception at Nuremberg, individual elements of hybridity have consistently caused concern amongst practitioners and legal theorists, largely around questions […]


Rethinking the Juridical System. Systematic Approach, Systemic Approach and Interpretation of Law

by F. Caroccia

The juridical system is not the essence of the things, it is an artificial organisation of elements, following a certain idea. It is conceived to settle conflicts, in order to find the solution that is more consistent with that original idea. In the juridical perspective, the logical coherency of the system becomes the necessary guarantee for non-arbitrary decisions. The present work is aimed at verifying this thesis, […]


Instances of Civil Law in North American Common Law Tradition:
Cause and Consideration in Quebec and Louisiana Civil Codes

by F. Delfini

A practical comparison between the two main legal system families can profit from some unique instances of civil law that lie in the vast North American continent. Reference is made to Quebec, for Canada, and Louisiana, for the US. Both locales are part of federal states ruled mainly by common law. The Canadian and US legal systems embed civil codes that refer to and define a requirement for the validity of the contract, the cause, that European civil codes mentioned, but did not dare to define. […]


Rationality and Counterfactual Legal Analysis

by A. Estella de Noriega

The aim of this article is to argue that counterfactual legal analysis should be used as a primary method in judicial interpretation of legislation. The article examines this issue assuming a rationality setting in which law is understood as a credibility device. Judges should show deference to the legislator when counterfactuals have been foreseen by the latter; in contrast, they might substitute their own judgment […]


Directive 2014/104/EU on Antitrust Damages Actions.
Some Considerations from the Perspective of Italian Law

by A. Nervi

European Parliament and Council Directive (EU) 2014/104 of 26 November 2014 introduces a common regulation for claims for damages caused by infringements of competition law. The implementation of the Directive in the Italian legal system may face some issues from a civil law perspective. One of these issues is the role of the judge in the evaluation of the claim for damages, especially in consideration of the restrictions […]



Training Young Lawyers in the European Mediation Framework: It’s Time to Devise a New Pedagogy for Conflict Management and Dispute Resolution

by L. Cominelli

Mediation as a dispute resolution method is being rediscovered today in Western legal systems. Modern jurisdictions now tend to promote mediation according to a ‘formal legislative approach’, based on recommendations issued by international organizations, in response to the pressure of public opinion that shows discontent with constant crisis in the justice system. […]



Uber and the Sharing Economy

by A. Di Amato

Sharing economy is an economy system in which assets or services are shared between private individuals, either for free or for a fee, typically by means of the internet. It consists of two different business models. The first business model is the offering of goods or services by businesses through internet and/or mobile apps. In the second business model, business entities create a web platform where […]


Italy and Kafalah: Reinventing Traditional Perspectives to Accommodate Diversity?

by A. Marotta

In September 2013, the Italian Court of Cassation introduced a new principle: in certain well-defined circumstances, local authorities cannot refuse to issue entry visas, for purposes of family reunification, to foreign minors taken under kafalah by Italian citizens residing in Italy. The Court was asked to determine whether it was possible to place Italian and foreign citizens on the same level in matters of kafalah and family reunification. […]


The Prohibition of Gametes’ Donation: When the Constitutional Court ‘Decides to Decide’

by E. Prascina

The paper addresses the prohibition on gamete donation, which was recently revoked by a landmark judgment of the Italian Constitutional Court. In the first part, it explores the social and cultural context to and political debate regarding the Italian law on medically assisted reproduction. It then sets out a framework for analysing the progressive erosion of the ban. It presents the Court’s clear intention finally to adopt a position, […]






Antigone and Portia (1959)

by T. Ascarelli

The problem of the law is a problem of all men, and is one that each of us must confront on a daily basis. Therefore, maybe, when symbolising its terms, we can call upon wise men before appealing to academics, and upon poets before turning to scholars. And this is why the mind naturally shifts its focus onto what is, possibly, the most perfect of all plays: Sophocles’ Antigone [...]


What Is to Be Done? Tullio Ascarelli on the Theory of Legal Interpretation

by C. Crea

The teachings of Tullio Ascarelli, a well-known scholar of commercial law and of comparative law on the international scene, has left a lasting mark on Italian legal culture insofar as they are one of the most elegant and complex expressions of the ‘revolt against formalism’ and the need to go beyond the folklore of the ‘old Italian style’. The centrality of the theory of legal interpretation […]


In Memoriam: Professor J.H. Merryman

by C. Amodio

This section of ‘The Italian Law Journal’ ends on a sad note. John Henry Merryman, a long time Professor at the Stanford law faculty, an internationally renowned figure in comparative law, a path-breaking scholar in that he was, inter alia, the first common law trained lawyer to explore our legal system, passed away at the age of 95, on 3 August 2015. Native of Portland, Oregon, Merryman joined the Stanford law faculty in 1953 [...]



Transnational Economic Constitutionalism in the Varieties of Capitalism

by G. Teubner

Notwithstanding the ordoliberal theories and the theories critical of a world ‘economic constitution’, globalization has not produced a unitary economic constitution, but a fragmented constitution of collisions: ie a metaconstitution of constitutional conflicts, whose conflicting units are no longer the national States, but the regimes of transnational production.  The alternative (developed for national States by Franz Böhm and […]


Structured Error. Case Study on a Discourse Logic of Comparative Law

by B. Lomfeld

Taking legal reactions on errors in contract formation (the ‘law of errors’) as a paradigm, this case study outlines the method of a ‘discursive comparative law’. Following a critical view on the prevailing methods of comparative law (I), the essay explores the idea of ‘deliberative comparisons’ between legal cultures (II). A ‘discourse logic’ compares structures of legal argumentation in different jurisdictions and reveals its […]


Discussing a Reform of the Senate. A Comparison between Italy and Canada

by E. Arban

In March 2015, the Italian Chamber of Deputies voted on a far-reaching constitutional reform; assuming a successful outcome of the long and complex amendment iter, this reform will have the effect to radically alter (among other things) the role, nature and composition of the Senate and of the perfect bicameral system currently in place. Interestingly enough, Italy is not the only country currently engaged in a political and institutional […]



Right to the City or Urban Commoning? Thoughts on the Generative Transformation of Property Law

by U. Mattei and A. Quarta

The economic and political transformations determined by the rise of neoliberalism are usually studied at a state dimension, while the urban one is quite ignored. Nevertheless, the government of the city has been influenced by global and national recent changes and all the municipal sectors have been touched by the austerity’s recipe. The decrease of urban public spaces, their privatizations as well as gentrification transform city planning […]



The Flow of Personal Data on the Internet: The Italian and European Google Cases

by F.G. Viterbo

The recent judgement of the European Court of Justice of 13 May 2014 (hereinafter: the Judgement) focused on the activity of the Google platform as a provider of indexed content, including personal data; this activity consists of locating information published on the web by third parties, indexing it automatically, storing it temporarily, and finally, making it available to internet users according to a particular order of preference. The Court has […]


Are Foreigners Entitled to a Right to Housing?

by L.E. Perriello

Under the reciprocity clause set forth by Art 16 of the Provisions on the Law in General, foreigners are entitled to the same civil rights as citizens, as long as such rights are afforded to citizens in the foreigners’ countries of origin. Still, Art 16 must be constitutionally interpreted so as to accomplish the full protection of human rights. Therefore, reciprocity does not apply to the fundamental rights. Therefore, reciprocity does not apply to the […]





The Italian Law Journal: Challenges and Opportunities 

by G. Calabresi

An Italian Law Journal, published biannually online in English, with an advisory board comprising not only of the most distinguished of European Scholars, but also of significant ones from Brazil, China, Japan, and the United States, and focusing on private law! One can only imagine what – formalist, totally 19th Century Code centered, but still very great – Italian scholars of not so long ago, would be saying about the enterprise! [...]


Criticism. From the Outskirts of a World Without a Centre

by P. Femia

On February 1433 at the university of Pavia the humanist Lorenzo Valla attacked the eminent jurist Bartolo da Sassoferrato, arguing that contemporary legal thinking was intellectual garbage. Jurists, all bartolians, forced him to leave the university. Symbol of a division that has never really been resolved, this story provides two dialectical images for an exercise in counter-narcissism for legal scholars. Valla and Bartolo show us the salvific [...]


Constitutional Norms and Civil Law Relationships

by P. Perlingieri

This essay provides a critical account of the long-established scholarly views according to which constitutional norms have a merely programmatic nature, inapt to be directly applied in private law relationships and hence to be utilized as hermeneutical tools when interpreting statutory law. Instead, as this essay shows, courts make use of constitutional norms extensively, applying them not only indirectly – that is in the presence [...]



Data as Tradeable Commodity and New Measures for their Protection

by A. De Franceschi and M. Lehmann

Information, particularly important, significant and relevant information, as illustrated by current Big Data or Wikileaks and Prism or more recently Tempora, is today’s ‘digital gold’. From an economic perspective it is therefore relevant to know whether and what kind of data content can be protected. The key question to be answered is therefore whether data can be recognised in law as ‘protectable rights’. In the digital world, data [...]


The Procompetitive Interpretation of Italian Private Law

by F. Longobucco

This paper investigates the opportunity of a Procompetitive interpretation of Private Law through an interdisciplinary analysis of Competition Law with Contract Law. The purpose of the research is to demonstrate that the traditional Civil Law might be differently considered and interpreted in the specific market where contractual obligation arises. Under this point of view, for example, it is necessary to adopt a new approach [...]


Children Born Out of Wedlock: The End of an Anachronistic Discrimination

by A. Valongo

After a historical and comparative overview regarding the discrimination of children in the perspective of the European Court for Human Rights, the aim of the paper is to examine an important shift that international standards and conventions have recently brought about in the Italian landscape of filiation: the Italian law reform 2012-13, which is designed to abolish the legal disabilities of all children born from both married and [...]




by S. Zorzetto

Reasonableness is a popular notion in the current European legal thinking and jurisprudence. As is well known, its uses are widespread in all subjects though its real meaning is still open to debate. Many different interpretations and uses coexist in common parlance. In particular, its boundaries in private law with good faith, fairness, due care, proportionality, rationality, equity and similar evaluative notions have still to be clarified. According to [...]



​Remedy for Fraud in Cir vs. Fininvest: Damages or Specific Performance

by S. Pagliantini

The Supreme Court’s judgment ruling in favour of Cir’s independent action for damages against Fininvest brings to an end proceedings that originated from a judicial decision setting aside the Mondadori arbitration award, a decision that Fininvest had obtained by bribing one of the judges and that had led Cir to reach an out-of-court settlement of the dispute. As far as the Supreme Court is concerned, that settlement is valid and the harm [...]